Are the police being properly policed?

When I moved to South Georgia, I decided there wouldn’t be much I would say “no” to. I was going to try new things, keep an open mind, and learn as much as I could about everything. One of those things was participating in the Citizens Police Academy near my town. I joined for many reasons, but one reason in particular was my fascination with how much people in smaller communities love their police officers. Writing for All On Georgia, we frequently share articles about the police department and the sheriff’s office and comments usually never stray from ‘Way to go!’ and ‘Great job, guys!’ I was like a bug to the light on this issue, especially coming from Metro Atlanta where the public-police partnership is basically non-existent.

Personally, I’ve never had a terrible experience with any law enforcement officer. I grew up in a community where the cops talked to kids, came by the neighborhood pool, and talked to you about listening to your parents. I’ve also had the opportunity to talk several courteous officers with a mild sense of humor out of giving me a traffic ticket – or ten. But it’s amazing what the media can do when they have the ability to push an agenda 24/7.

Like most, I was mortified by the story of the DeKalb officers who entered the wrong home and ended up shooting the homeowner and fatally wounding his dog. Like most, my heart aches to see the calls for violence against officers around the nation for no reason other than their employment status. Like most, I have read the news articles, seen the live coverage, and watched on social media as the respect for the thin blue line fizzles into an untouchable pixie dust while all-things-policing have become racially charged and politically motivated. There’s a huge problem between the public and police right now.


(Photo: Lansing State Journal)

Just recently, I saw an article out of Michigan go viral. A “well-behaved” teenager was pulled over by an officer for flashing his lights. The article, which included body camera footage, was cluttering my Facebook feed for days, featuring the officer as some sort of animal who yanked a kid from a car, threw his phone into traffic, and emptied his weapon. SEVERAL news articles would have you think that. CNN’s headline read, “Cop kicks teens phone out of hand, shoots 7 times.” HuffingtonPost’s said, “Unarmed Teen Flashed Lights at cop and ended up dead.” The body camera footage might even have you thinking that, too, considering what was released is cut off as soon as the actual scuffle begins, but an independent Google search shows you images of the officer in the hospital, bruised and bloodied. That picture didn’t appear in one viral article, but it isn’t a hoax and certainly changes the dialogue about the incident.

I don’t know the full extent of what happened there. I can only draw conclusions from the information that is available, but it’s getting old watching people draw conclusions from a single source with one issue when in other aspects of life, they’ll trust anyone but the mainstream media. Many of my anti-government friends who question everything else reported by the media are quick to jump to the defense of anyone but the officer when a scuffle emerges.

In the story from Michigan, the teen may have been unarmed, but I’m not sure how that’s relevant in a physical fight. You don’t need a weapon to kill someone and being a police officer doesn’t make you any less of a person. If it were your husband, or son, or father, how long would you want them to wait before fighting for their life? ‘Public servant’ doesn’t translate to ‘public sacrifice.’

Consider this video from Laurens County back in the late 1990’s. The dashcam video shows three and a half minutes of heartwrenching and gruesome footage of a standoff between Deputy Kyle Dinkheller and a deranged veteran who ends up loading a rifle in front of the deputy, charging him, and emptying the magazine – killing Deputy Dinkheller. All of this is on the video. If you watch it, you would stare -dumbfounded- wondering why the deputy didn’t fire sooner.

(WARNING: The video is graphic and horrific in language and content)

It’s difficult to place ourselves in their shoes, and I am glad we hold our public servants to such a high standard of integrity and expertise, but I also know that I am not cut out to be a cop. Are you? I think back to a few weeks ago when my CPA class had to use a gun simulator on a traffic stop that escalated. We were given a gun and had to decide when to ‘use force’ on our aggressor. It was a computer game, essentially, and the ‘perpetrator’ scared the living daylights out of me when he started moving and shaking and whipping his hands in and out of his pockets. I KNEW what was coming on a game and I still reacted by firing all six bullets in my gun. And on my ride-along, we responded to a call in an area that I know that if I lived in it, I would probably walk around with my gun drawn 24/7. So, I ask again…your judgement casts easy, but would your glass house weather the storm if the shoe was on the other foot?

I also have to wonder if the people who are so angry about law enforcement officers have actually had a bad experience themselves, or if they are just living vicariously through stories and victims in the media. These stories are happening – there is no denying the incidents – but is it as often as we are led to believe?

It is almost cliche now to say ‘there are bad people in every industry,’ but it’s true. It’s just not every industry that has open records requests and the media breathing down their neck on a daily basis. When I make a mistake in my job, I fix it and the world keeps spinning. When an accountant doesn’t properly balance a sheet, the world continues turning. When a board of elected officials votes to do something unscrupulous, the world. keeps. turning.

What I’ve found is that when an officer does do something wrong, other officers are quick to point that out or condemn the action. Very few of them are looking to cast the wide net and taint the entire force or industry, if you will. And if you talk to your local officers, you’ll find that most of them don’t look at the world the way the media portrays them to be looking at the world.

This isn’t a defense of the bad ones, but rather a question of whether or not we are fighting the right fight, or just fighting to fight. I don’t know what the answer is. We cannot disarm law enforcement officers and we certainly cannot disarm the media. The difference is that the media comes out unscathed while exacerbating what is a very bad time to be a police officer in the United States. Perhaps the activists who would like to see reform on aspects of policing should save their energy for stories which expressly show wrongdoing, so not only can proper action be taken, but when there is a ‘victory for the public,’ it is not at the expense of the integrity of a movement.


3 thoughts on “Are the police being properly policed?

  1. Pingback: The Police. | Hair Blowers to Lawn Mowers

  2. Ron McClellan

    Great article. I generally support law enforcement. They do have a tough job, and as Jessica points out, most cops are good cops. But we need to examine what “most” means too. I’ve seen folks say “you can’t judge the 99 good cops, by the actions of the one bad cop.

    Well, I think that “bad cop” number is low. Not sure the percentage reaches double digits, but I suspect it’s closer to 10% than 1%. I have a fair amount of experience to base that on too. I wasn’t an angel growing up . . .or even as a grown up. I wasn’t a thug or a hardened criminal, but I was just adventurous enough and mischievous enough to find myself on the wrong end of dealing with police. And not all of them handled correctly by the officer I was dealing with.

    In one case, a police officer pulled over and let me pass him, then promptly turned on the lights and siren. I had no clue what was up, as I wasn’t doing anything wrong. I pulled over, and the officers first words were “Now I got ya!” I was like “what?” He started complaining about something ripping up and down a road behind his house. I just let him go on for a minute, then I said “What the hell are you talking about?” I was genuinely confused. He started cussing me out, and I interrupted and asked what I did to get pulled over. I wasn’t waving my hands around or anything. He slammed me up against his car. I asked again, “What did I do?”

    He, with deliberate sarcasm said, “Well let me see . . .following to close.” He cuffed me, then he then began writing the ticket. During the course of the ticket, he removed my wallet from my pocket and looked at the driver license. A strange look formed on his face, and he finished writing the ticket. Then he uncuffed me, and in a decidedly unapologetic tone, said “Sorry I thought you were someone else.” left me there with that ticket, for something I didn’t do (Who rides a cops butt on a motorcycle?)

    I was also with a buddy, and we pulled into the turn lane behind a cop (Fla Highway Patrol) he was kinda hanging out in an intersection a little, and heavy traffic was coming from the opposite direction, and he backed up a bit, out of the upcoming traffic. We’d left him the room to do so.

    Then . . .the light turned green . . . .and he hit the gas and slammed right into us. He’d left it in reverse. Guess who got the ticket? I was there. I saw the whole thing. The guy behind us saw the whole thing. Herb fought the ticket. Cop lied, The three of us didn’t lie and Herb got stuck with thicket, the bill and now court costs. Wonderful.

    On the other hand, I’ve been straight up arrested before,(minor stuff, but not minor enough to not be arrested, heheh) and even the arresting officers were either stoic and kinda neutral, or even downright nice guys.

    Bad cops are out there, but they aren’t particularly rare, even though I do think they are a substantial minority. But it’s more than 1% of them. Nowadays, as I’ve settled down a bit, heheh, I have friends who are police officers. And while it seems to be an uncomfortable subject with them, pretty much every one of them I’ve touched on this topic with acknowledge they know at least one guy out there with him with a badge and a gun that they don’t think should be out there with a badge and a gun.


    Good Article Jessica: But. Police/Criminal Justice Reform? Excepting a few, really rare case, “the police” are not broken – because they represent the will of the political class – they are a projection of the will of the political class. Only when there is no definable will to project do they project their own will. When they are backed into a corner, absent a plan to survive and dominate the situation, is when things tend to really get nasty. And y’all ain’t seen nasty yet. Dallas has been losing so many officers and so fast that they have been making the news daily and for months. When the police are broken in a major city, then the bugs will fill the void. And when the bugs dominate, then the people will flee. This is a recipe for chaos. And this very real and rising chaos has been and is being manufactured in furtherance of a specific agenda. Ordo ab Chao. Report on this.


Have something to say?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s